Defending an Open Internet: i2Coalition Signs Joint Statement on the EU Digital Networks Act

Following the publication of the European Commission’s proposal for a Digital Networks Act (DNA), joined 37 groups and another four individual signatories in a letter advising that the legislation in its current state risks doing far more harm than good, while introducing complexity instead of simplicity. We argue for a clear and evidence-based telecoms framework that upholds and protects net neutrality so that the Internet can function properly.

The letter reads in part:

“Given their substantial impact on the European digital ecosystem, we consider that these proposals raise serious questions regarding their proportionality and necessity. These proposals risk weakening key safeguards that protect European consumers and businesses, including SMEs and startups that rely on open and predictable Internet conditions to compete and scale across the EU, whilst undermining the digital single market as a whole.

“The proposals for incorporation of the Open Internet Regulation (OIR) into the DNA risk undermining the principle of net neutrality by weakening an established and well-functioning framework, undermining the legal certainty that has ensured its enforcement across the EU. The DNA proposal removes 18 out of 19 recitals of the OIR, eliminating key interpretative elements that have provided essential clarifications on the scope and application of net neutrality rules in the EU and have been central to the development of CJEU [Court of Justice of the European Union] case law and BEREC [ Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications] guidelines.”

This action is in addition to our feedback during the European Commission’s public consultation period.

What is the DNA?
The DNA would embed the European Electronic Communications Code (EECC) review into a broader overhaul of Europe’s digital infrastructure framework in an effort to address spectrum policy, wholesale access rules, level-playing-field concerns, and a potential revisiting of net neutrality provisions in light of evolving traffic and interconnection dynamics. A regulatory framework that simplifies rules, improves harmonisation across Member States, and reinforces Europe’s digital competitiveness is an important goal. At the same time, the Digital Networks Act should carefully preserve the architectural distinctions that underpin the functioning of the Internet.

You can read the full text of the letter below.